Are College Admissions Test-Optional Policies a Scam? Here’s What You Need to Know
Dear Parents Who Actually Care,
College admissions test-optional policies sound great on the surface. However, in reality, they could be putting your child at a serious disadvantage. Many families believe these policies create fairness in the admissions process. Yet, when you dig deeper, it becomes clear that they often work against students who don’t submit test scores.
For years, I’ve watched parents fall for one of the biggest lies in college admissions:
📢 The Great Test-Optional Scam.
You’ve heard the claims:
“Test scores don’t matter anymore! The SAT and ACT are outdated! College admissions are finally fair!”
🚨 That’s a myth.
In truth, college admissions test-optional policies don’t level the playing field—they tilt it against your child.
If you don’t understand how the system really works, your child could be at a major disadvantage.
Let’s break it down.
How College Admissions Test-Optional Policies Help Schools—Not Students
Colleges love marketing test-optional admissions as an “inclusive” approach. However, behind the scenes, these policies serve a completely different purpose.
Rather than helping students, test-optional policies help colleges manipulate their rankings.
Here’s how the game is played:
- Only students with high SAT/ACT scores submit them.
- Consequently, this artificially inflates the school’s reported average test scores.
- Applications skyrocket because students believe they have a better shot.
- As a result, the school rejects more students, increasing its selectivity ranking.
From the outside, colleges appear more competitive without actually improving the quality of education.
Meanwhile, students face a very different reality.
📉 Students who submit test scores are accepted at rates 2-3x higher than those who don’t.
In other words, if your child doesn’t submit SAT or ACT scores, they are competing against applicants who did—which puts them at a clear disadvantage.
Unfortunately, the problem runs even deeper.
College Admissions Test-Optional vs. Test-Blind: Understanding the Difference
Many families mistakenly believe that colleges completely ignore SAT and ACT scores under test-optional policies. However, that’s not true at all.
🚨 Test-Optional ≠ Test-Blind.
Key Differences You Need to Know:
✔ Test-Optional Colleges: SAT/ACT scores are not required, but they are considered if submitted.
✔ Test-Blind Colleges: These schools will not review SAT/ACT scores under any circumstances.
Since most schools are test-optional, not test-blind, students who submit scores gain an advantage over those who don’t.
Therefore, if your child submits test scores, colleges WILL take them into account. Furthermore, SAT/ACT scores continue to impact merit-based scholarships.
Without test scores, students must rely entirely on subjective factors like essays, extracurriculars, and recommendations.
For instance, applying to a test-optional college without SAT/ACT scores is like going to a job interview where salary expectations are “optional.”
Sure, you don’t HAVE to provide a number…
But if another candidate does—and it’s strong—who has the advantage?
This is why test-optional policies secretly favor students who submit scores.
The College Admissions Test-Optional Trend Is Fading—Here’s Why
Not long ago, test-optional admissions were being celebrated. Today, however, many schools are reversing course.
So, why are they making this change?
Because they’ve realized something shocking:
📊 Students who submitted test scores performed better in college.
As a result, several top universities are bringing back SAT/ACT requirements:
💥 MIT? Back to requiring SAT/ACT.
💥 Georgia Tech? No longer test-optional.
💥 Purdue? Same deal.
Clearly, the trend is shifting. Colleges are recognizing that objective measures still matter.
If your child isn’t prepared for these policy changes, they could end up at a disadvantage.
Who Really Loses in College Admissions Test-Optional Policies?
At first glance, test-optional policies sound like a great idea.
However, in practice, they hurt the very students they were designed to help.
🚨 Here’s who loses the most:
❌ First-generation college students (who don’t have the same resources as legacy applicants).
❌ Public school students (who may lack strong extracurriculars or private college counseling).
❌ Transfer students (who often rely on test scores to stand out).
❌ Students applying for scholarships (many of which still require SAT/ACT scores).
Without standardized test scores, admissions become even more subjective. As a result, the process often favors students from wealthier backgrounds.
And let’s be real:
When your child applies for grad school, internships, or jobs at major firms like Goldman Sachs…
📉 Nobody cares about their Anime Club presidency.
They want objective proof of ability. And strong test scores provide that.
How Smart Parents Are Navigating College Admissions Test-Optional Policies
Savvy families are avoiding the test-optional trap. Instead, they are:
✅ Investing in top-tier SAT/ACT prep.
✅ Maximizing merit-based scholarship opportunities.
✅ Making sure their child has every competitive advantage.
In reality, a strong SAT/ACT score unlocks more college options, bigger scholarships, and stronger applications for grad school & jobs.
Since college is already a $200K+ investment, making the right moves now can pay off in the long run.
The Truth About College Admissions Test-Optional Policies (And What You Should Do Next)
I could tell you what you want to hear:
🥴 “Oh yes, test scores don’t matter anymore! Everything is fair and wonderful!”
But I’d rather tell you the truth.
🎯 Test-optional policies do NOT mean test-irrelevant.
🎯 SAT/ACT scores still matter—and will continue to matter.
🎯 Ignoring test prep puts your child at a disadvantage.
Want a Competitive Edge in College Admissions? Here’s How I Can Help
I work with a select number of families who are:
✅ Serious about college success.
✅ Willing to invest in real results.
✅ Ready to hear the truth about admissions.
My Comprehensive Program Includes:
🎯 Proven SAT/ACT test prep.
🎯 Strategic college application planning.
🎯 School selection based on REAL data.
🎯 Standout college essays.
🎯 Interview coaching that actually works.
⚠ Spots fill up fast—don’t wait until it’s too late.
